Closing comments on old entries

Based on what Jeremy has worked up already, I have created a small little MT application that will close the entry to comments (and pings if you so desire) for any entries older than a given number of days (defaults to five).

So, download one of the following, unpack it, and place mt-close.cgi in your base MT directory. Be sure to set the permissions of the file so that it can be executed.

Then, to use it, just bring up http://your.mt.url/mt-directory/mt-close.cgi in your browser of choice.

Enjoy!

Update: (2003-12-27 12:10)

The bug Neil found is now fixed. Just download the script again.

108 TrackBacks

Jeremy has published perl code to autoclose comments for posts in Moveable Type that have grown old to prevent SPAM in those comments. Here is the link to the hack. Thank him of you use his code! There is another trackback entry in that blog which talk... Read More

How to close comments on entries en-masse, without needing to use an SQL command. Read More

How to close comments on entries en-masse, without needing to use an SQL command. Read More

A Better Comment Spam Solution from Ramblings of a Code Monkey on December 27, 2003 1:45 PM

David Raynes just posted a more elegant solution to closing comments than I could come up with. He has developed a CGI which will close entries for the specified number of days for the specified blog(s). While this is similar... Read More

A Better Comment Spam Solution from Ramblings of a Code Monkey on December 27, 2003 1:46 PM

David Raynes just posted a more elegant solution to closing comments than I could come up with. He has developed a CGI which will close entries for the specified number of days for the specified blog(s). While this is similar... Read More

David Raynes: Closing comments on old entries. I'm going to take this one for a spin. When it comes to... Read More

David Raynes has come up with yet another great plugin for MovableType. The MT-Close plugin allows you to go through your entire blog and close the entries older than "x" day. So, if you don't want people to comment on... Read More

Geek day from When Knitting Was a Manly Art on December 29, 2003 10:30 PM

Today turned into a geek out day. A couple rounds of the Dubblemossa and then decided to bite the bullet... Read More

Comment spam has been bugging me for some time. I've looked at some anti-comment spam solutions and have decided to go with MT-Blacklist at the moment... Read More

Goodbye spam! from Mind of Knowledge on January 12, 2004 3:41 PM

Stopped using MT Blacklist Comment Spam Read More

Goodbye spam! from Mind of Knowledge on January 12, 2004 3:44 PM

Stopped using MT Blacklist Comment Spam Read More

David Raynes: Closing comments on old entries... Read More

Edited I'm not starting up Burningbird but a lot of good people were hit badly by a very sophisticated comment spam attack, including the Wayward webloggers who I'm responsible to. The attackers this time only posted three comments to each post, each w... Read More

Edited I'm not starting up Burningbird but a lot of good people were hit badly by a very sophisticated comment spam attack, including the Wayward webloggers who I'm responsible to. The attackers this time only posted three comments to each post, each w... Read More

I haven’t commented on Comment Spam for some time. I haven’t felt the need. Since installing MT-Blacklist, I have had... Read More

Edited I'm not starting up Burningbird but a lot of good people were hit badly by a very sophisticated comment spam attack, including the Wayward webloggers who I'm responsible to. The attackers this time only posted three comments to each post, each w... Read More

My web host (friends of mine) unplugged the comments module after the first 1,000 spams came in within two hours. I think you can still read comments but you can't write them. I'm going to try installing David Raynes' script that lets you turn off comm... Read More

In an effort to head off blogspam, I'm now using David Raynes' comment-closing cgi script. From now on, any entries... Read More

update I'm using Dave Sifry's tiny Perl script instead. In an effort to head off blogspam, I'm now using David... Read More

Edited I'm not starting up Burningbird but a lot of good people were hit badly by a very sophisticated comment spam attack, including the Wayward webloggers who I'm responsible to. The attackers this time only posted three comments to each post, each w... Read More

Six Apart releases Movable Type 2.66 which brings new features to protect a weblog against comments spamming: a throttling measure... Read More

Six Apart vient de publier Movable Type 2.66 qui apporte son lot de mesures anti-spam: un délai configurable entre deux commentaires en provenance de la même adresse IP le bannissement automatique de l'adresse IP en cas de création d'un nombre... Read More

Edited I'm not starting up Burningbird but a lot of good people were hit badly by a very sophisticated comment spam attack, including the Wayward webloggers who I'm responsible to. The attackers this time only posted three comments to each post, each w... Read More

Edited I'm not starting up Burningbird but a lot of good people were hit badly by a very sophisticated comment spam attack, including the Wayward webloggers who I'm responsible to. The attackers this time only posted three comments to each post, each w... Read More

Edited I'm not starting up Burningbird but a lot of good people were hit badly by a very sophisticated comment spam attack, including the Wayward webloggers who I'm responsible to. The attackers this time only posted three comments to each post, each w... Read More

Edited I'm not starting up Burningbird but a lot of good people were hit badly by a very sophisticated comment spam attack, including the Wayward webloggers who I'm responsible to. The attackers this time only posted three comments to each post, each w... Read More

Edited I'm not starting up Burningbird but a lot of good people were hit badly by a very sophisticated comment spam attack, including the Wayward webloggers who I'm responsible to. The attackers this time only posted three comments to each post, each w... Read More

Concerning Spam from Learning Movable Type on January 24, 2004 12:00 AM

Spammers have discovered bloggers and sooner or later if you allow comments or trackback pings on your Movable Type weblog you will get spammed. Weblog spam is appearing in many flavors: 1) Basic comment spam. The spammer leaves a short... Read More

Concerning Spam from Learning Movable Type on January 24, 2004 12:01 AM

Spammers have discovered bloggers and sooner or later if you allow comments or trackback pings on your Movable Type weblog you will get spammed. Weblog spam is appearing in many flavors: 1) Basic comment spam. The spammer leaves a short... Read More

Concerning Spam from Learning Movable Type on January 25, 2004 11:15 PM

Spammers have discovered bloggers and sooner or later if you allow comments or trackback pings on your Movable Type weblog you will get spammed. Weblog spam is appearing in many flavors: 1) Basic comment spam. The spammer leaves a short... Read More

More Comment Spam. from The Wily Filipino on January 27, 2004 4:34 PM

Wrote this last night: Right now I'm just too angry to think straight. Got back home from the faculty party... Read More

As if spammers hadn't yet realised that I'm not interested in enlarging non-existent appendages, or joining an online betting cult,... Read More

comments for older entries from TJ's Weblog "Technology, Venture Capital and Entrepreneurship" on February 3, 2004 11:48 AM

I discovered David Raynes wonderful tool to close old comments last night. Now comments for entries older then 30 days will be blocked. If you want to leave me a message please mail me. Sorry but I won't spend my... Read More

MT Close Comments from A Sassy Lawyer's Journal on February 27, 2004 5:22 AM

I downloaded and installed a little script to close comments in old entries. I chose those older then 120 days. For some reason, even the recent ones--including those still appearing on the index page--are now closed for comments. And I can't figure ou... Read More

...with the David Raynes script. works like a charm. thanks David :)... Read More

I upgraded both Gallery and Movable Type to the current versions. Each of the packages is "just about" to release their next big mondo release, and I can't wait to see if things are about to get better. See, the problem with Gallery is that pictures ar... Read More

Earlier this week (maybe it was over the weekend?) I installed MT Blacklist. it! Today I installed David Raynes' comment closing script and closed all posts older than 45 days. I'm just tired of the comment spammers. I'll probably install... Read More

I finally upgraded to MT 2.661. Wanna know why? Because of David Raynes's Optional-Redirect v0.11 That's right. You can mouse over your commenter's names again, without seeing your own url. I know there was a good reason for that feature... Read More

MT-Close plugin from Karmakars.com on March 17, 2004 5:15 PM

If you do blogs (Photoblogs, weblogs, mobileblogs) soomer or later your comment entry area becomes prone to spam And this is particularly true when you have old posts left open which you either forgot to close. My first recommendation would... Read More

This is the simplest way I've found to close of comments on older entries, so simple in fact it took me less that 10 minutes and it worked first time (unheard of in my world). I've not installed blacklist properly... Read More

Closing comments on old posts from Sharondippity - Moveable Type on March 21, 2004 3:36 PM

I installed this script in hopes it will slow down the spam commenters (fucking low lifers). I'm cleaning up my scraggly side yard today. I'm taking lotsa breaks. I couldn't ask for nicer weather. Moxie is helping by napping nearby.... Read More

Like many Movable Type bloggers, I have recently received a lot of comment spam on this site, which I am quick to delete but which sorely gripes me. I sat down to solve the problem today and was delighted to... Read More

Weblog publishers who utilise the Movable Type system are particularly susceptible to comment sp*m. Until Six Apart release an updated version of Movable Type containing fixes for the current vulnerabilities, the only way to counteract comment... Read More

Weblog publishers who utilise the Movable Type system are particularly susceptible to comment sp*m. Until Six Apart release an updated version of Movable Type containing fixes for the current vulnerabilities, the only way to counteract comment... Read More

Non è più possibile commentare notiziole più vecchie di una settimana. [leggi...] Read More

Comment Spam from ArborBlogs on April 5, 2004 9:14 PM

Comment Spam seems to be a big problem with ArborBloggers. Stephen spotted some on the Cool Cities Task Force Blog, and AirBeagle got hit too. Personally, I'm starting to see comment spam every other day on my site. So what's... Read More

Dusty Shades from Charleen's Fiberblog on April 10, 2004 12:00 AM

I washed the cotton skeins and put them up to dry today. The grey cotton really gave the colors a dusty look. I used a semi-low immersion method so the variations were expected (and wanted). It wouldn't work for... Read More

Dusty Shades from Charleen's Fiberblog on April 10, 2004 12:02 AM

I washed the cotton skeins and put them up to dry today. The grey cotton really gave the colors a dusty look. I used a semi-low immersion method so the variations were expected (and wanted). It wouldn't work for... Read More

Dusty Shades from Charleen's Fiberblog on April 10, 2004 12:34 AM

I washed the cotton skeins and put them up to dry today. The grey cotton really gave the colors a dusty look. I used a semi-low immersion method so the variations were expected (and wanted). It wouldn't work for... Read More

Just installed MT-Close, a movabletype plugin which allows one to turn off the ability to leave comments on older posts. It has settings for the age at which comments are turned off. After a couple of strange comments were left... Read More

Difendi il tuo blog dallo spam from Linkaggio: storie, attualita', tecnologia e tempo libero... on May 20, 2004 7:01 PM

Gli spammers hanno scoperto i blog, s'intravedono già © primi risultati negli USA, e tra poco anche in Italia le funzioni tipiche d'interazione dei weblog: trackback e commenti saranno presi d'assalto. Ecco le tipologie di spam che possono presentarsi ... Read More

Difendi il tuo blog dallo spam from Linkaggio: storie, attualita', tecnologia e tempo libero... on May 20, 2004 7:02 PM

Gli spammers hanno scoperto i blog, s'intravedono già © primi risultati negli USA, e tra poco anche in Italia le funzioni tipiche d'interazione dei weblog: trackback e commenti saranno presi d'assalto. Ecco le tipologie di spam che possono presentarsi ... Read More

Victory II from The Politburo Diktat on May 22, 2004 1:53 PM

Update: More complete victory over comment spammers needed. In addition to mt-blacklist, I also installed David Raynes' script to close comments and renamed the basic comments script, from mt-comments.cgi to super-secret encoded name. :) Per Comrade De... Read More

This is why you should - A] Have your blog mail you comment notifications B] Institute a blacklist and comment scanning C] Periodically close older comments We need an afterschool special on this, I swear...... Read More

Godsend from Say Uncle on June 3, 2004 4:41 PM

Been inundated with comment spam lately, which just pisses me off to no end. Thanks to this handy plug in by David Raynes, comments will... Read More

Buh-Bye Spammers! from Blog-Her :: Pandora's Box on June 6, 2004 7:08 PM

There are ways to fight spam without MT3.0 Read More

mt-improve from Quiet Thoughts at the Midnight Café on June 9, 2004 8:43 AM

I made some changes to the templates and the MT... Read More

mt-improve from Sum of all shiny parts on June 17, 2004 1:18 AM

I made some changes to the templates and the MT program today, cos I learnt a bit more about plug-ins.... Read More

Comment spam got me down, so all threads more than twelve days old will be closed to comments from now on. Thanks to Chris in the comments here for pointing my way to this plugin. Now can anyone tell me... Read More

Whose blog is this? from Classical Values on June 29, 2004 10:05 AM

After a long litany of being spammed with many hundreds of comments, being publicly taunted and challenged by a spammer (or spam defender), and after months of abusive comments, I am now almost ready to turn off comments, because it... Read More

Well, that was a first... I turned on my computer tonight and found no less than thirty trackback spams. It took a while to remove them, but I added the domain to Blacklist and banned two more IPs. I normally... Read More

The quickest fix for all of my troubles, a fix compatible with MT3, is the closing of old comments. No way to post comments, no comment spam. I'm using David Raynes' MT-Close to close all comments over five days old, or posts without any comments whats... Read More

After getting more and more annoyed at the prevalence of comment spam, I went hunting around for a good way to automatically close comments on entries here after a certain number of days. What I stumbled upon was a few... Read More

Spam from Bacon, Cheese and Oatcakes on September 10, 2004 6:38 AM

For the first time in a very long time - well since I had mt-blacklist and mt-commentsclosed installed - I've... Read More

Fann lítið sætt forrit sem lokar á athugasemdir sem eru eldri en X daga gamlar í Movable Type. Sé að vísu ekki betur en það hafi lokað á athugasemdir á nýrri skrifum líka (ég valdi 5 daga) en mér er... Read More

Fann lítið sætt forrit sem lokar á athugasemdir sem eru eldri en X daga gamlar í Movable Type. Sé að vísu ekki betur en það hafi lokað á athugasemdir á nýrri skrifum líka (ég valdi 5 daga) en mér er... Read More

Fann lítið sætt forrit sem lokar á athugasemdir sem eru eldri en X daga gamlar í Movable Type. Sé að vísu ekki betur en það hafi lokað á athugasemdir á nýrri skrifum líka (ég valdi 5 daga) en mér er... Read More

Fann lítið sætt forrit sem lokar á athugasemdir sem eru eldri en X daga gamlar í Movable Type. Sé að vísu ekki betur en það hafi lokað á athugasemdir á nýrri skrifum líka (ég valdi 5 daga) en mér er... Read More

Spam in blogs.. from The Underground Man on October 2, 2004 12:41 PM

So I seem to be getting an ever-increasing amount of spam comments in my blog these days. I delete them and ban the URLs promptly but it has only kept the problem manageable. Now I've added banning IPs and have... Read More

I love MT-Blacklist, but sometimes it just doesn't work fast enough with the updates to eliminate all spam - but I appreciate Jay Allen's hard work and think MT-Blacklist is pure genius. But to supplement that plug-in, I've also opted to use Rayne's MT... Read More

I love MT-Blacklist, but sometimes it just doesn't work fast enough with the updates to eliminate all spam - but I appreciate Jay Allen's hard work and think MT-Blacklist is pure genius. But to supplement that plug-in, I've also opted to use Rayne's MT... Read More

Entries on this blog will have their "Post A Comment" box disabled after 7 days. After deleting more than 40,000 spam comments using mt-blacklist, we got another 2000 spam comments over the weekend. Most of these are hitting old entry,... Read More

Even though I have the fantastic MT-Blacklist installed on my site, I still get tons of comment spams, both denials that get blocked but eat up resources, and spams for as-of-yet-un-blacklisted sites that eat up resources and my patience. The... Read More

Thank you Technodaddy for posting this on your linkblog!! David Raynes has a script that will close old comments. Go get it here..... Read More

Comment Spam from Living In Hormoney on November 6, 2004 10:17 AM

All of us get inundated with comment spam. I personally do not want a PW protected blog, at least not just yet, so I have used this MT application to close all the old entries to comments, so that only... Read More

Comment Spam from Living In Hormoney on November 7, 2004 11:02 AM

All of us get inundated with comment spam. I personally do not want a PW protected blog, at least not just yet, so I have used this MT application to close all the old entries to comments, so that only... Read More

I usually access my webspace via Fetch. For the while I was without a computer, I poked around in there via my cPanel's File Manager. Come to find out I've been publishing daily archives for a good long while (oops).... Read More

good juju on stopping blogspam from Words - big ones and little ones... on November 19, 2004 10:59 PM

stefanos got me onto this one: David Raynes: Closing comments on old entries... Read More

Steven pointed me at David Raynes' mt-close script. I used it to close lots of old entries. It is simple but it does seem to work. It may help you in your blog sp@m elimination efforts. More Later,... Read More

Steven pointed me at David Raynes' mt-close script. I used it to close lots of old entries. It is simple but it does seem to work. It may help you in your blog sp@m elimination efforts. More Later,... Read More

MT fixerier mot spam! from Carina´s tankar - Tankeboken on November 20, 2004 8:09 AM

Jag har nu stängt kommentarer och trackbacks för texter skrivna längra tillbaks än 14 dagar. Jag har också lagt in... Read More

Blogging note: I finally figured out how to install this wonderful script for closing old entries. The amount of daily spam seems to have seriously dropped off as a result. I'm not complaining. However, if you want to leave a... Read More

Blogging note: I finally figured out how to install this wonderful script for closing old entries. The amount of daily spam seems to have seriously dropped off as a result, and that's just in 24 hours. I'm not complaining. However,... Read More

I hate to have to do this, but I'm going to start closing comments on any entry that's over a week old. The comment spam has been getting insane, and I'm having trouble keeping up even with mt-blacklist. If you're... Read More

I must have received fifty+ spams today... The stupid thing (from their perspective) is that they actually don't have links to any sites. So I don't know what they're benefitting from this. MT-Blacklist misses them because there are no tokens to trigge... Read More

MT fixerier mot spam! from Carina´s tankar - Tankeboken on December 17, 2004 7:08 AM

Jag har nu stängt kommentarer och trackbacks för texter skrivna längre tillbaks än 14 dagar. Jag har också lagt in... Read More

En las últimas semanas los weblogs basados en el sistema Movable Type han sido afectados por ataques masivos de blogspam, muchas compañias que brindan hosting corporativa y personalmente quieren desactivar las opciones de comentarios en este tipo de bi... Read More

So, with comment spam coming in with apparently random character URLs now - making Blacklisting impossible - I'm taking more measures. First off is closing comments after 14 days. If you want to comment on an older posting, email me.... Read More

Spam! from :: Scottious.net :: on January 4, 2005 1:46 PM

Learning Movable Type: Concerning Spam A couple of weeks ago, I never really thought comment spam could affect me. I had comments wide open to anonymous commenters with the default settings that my CMS, Movable Type, provided. Spam Attack. One... Read More

Even though I have the fantastic MT-Blacklist installed on my site, I still get tons of comment spams, both denials that get blocked but eat up resources, and spams for as-of-yet-un-blacklisted sites that eat up resources and my patience. The... Read More

Due to the noticeable lack of dialogue around here lately (and at least a couple folks -- my wife and... Read More

Combatting Spam from NoelHeikkinen.com on January 14, 2005 7:59 PM

{ MOOD: Elated | NOISE: Kid's singing and cleaning } In an effort to battle spam, I have implemented a script that closes old entries to comments. Not many people post comments after a month, so I have chosen that... Read More

Finally finished de-gunking my blog of comment and trackback spam. I've implemented some of the suggestions found in the Six... Read More

Close Comments from have a nice day. on January 21, 2005 6:43 AM

While MT-Blacklist has been wonderful, it's just been way too much of a hassle having to empty my comments of... Read More

Script Help from Res Ipsa Loquitur on February 1, 2005 6:05 PM

I've been trying to install a script today to close trackback pings, and I can't get it to work. Anyone... Read More

Script Help from Res Ipsa Loquitur on February 1, 2005 11:08 PM

I've been trying to install a script today to close trackback pings, and I can't get it to work. Anyone... Read More

I've used David Raynes: Closing comments on old entries script to hopefully close trackback on Kristen's blog and at the same time I have started to play with some css for some learning time before I roll out a new... Read More

スパム対策の締めくくりとして、過去のコメントとトラックバックをクローズ(受付終了)させる方法を探しました。日本語のサイトにはなかなか良い記事がみつからず、腹をくくって例にã... Read More

nachdem, wie von einem unkenden kommentator richtig angekündigt, hier über die letzten tage eine regelrechte kommentarspamwelle hinweggezogen ist, habe ich jetzt erst einmal die notbremse gezogen. kommentare zu beiträgen, die älter als 15 tage sind, si... Read More

If you've tried to post a comment recently you probably got a 404 message. Due to the amount of comment... Read More

Fucking spammers!!! from My Single Mom Life on April 10, 2005 7:24 AM

As a result of massive spamming, you *must* be a TypeKey member in order to comment on an entry. Click here to register with the service or login. I apologize for the inconvenience, but these damn spammners are killing my... Read More

I like the idea of trackbacks, I think it's pretty cool because you can see what other people stumble across your incoherent ramblings. I've had to lockdown comments to require you to register with Six Apart and haven't had a... Read More

ÇöÀç »ç¿ëÇÏ´Â MT blacklist¸¸À¸·Îµµ »ó´çÇÑ ½ºÆÔ ¹æÁö È¿°ú°¡ ÀÖ¾ú´Âµ¥, »ç½Ç ±Ùº»ÀûÀÎ ½ºÆÔ Ä¿¸àÆ®¸¦ ¸·´Â °¡Àå ÁÁÀº ¹æ¹ýÀº Ä¿¸àÆ®¸¦ ´Ý´Â °Í. »ç½Ç ùÆäÀÌÁö¿¡ Ä¿¸àÆ®¸¸ ¿­·ÁÀÖÀ¸¸é µÇÁö ¾ÆÄ«À̺êÀÇ Ä¿¸àÆ®°¡ ¿­·ÁÀÖÀ» ÇÊ¿ä´Â ¾ø°Ú´Ù½Í¾úÁö¸¸. ±×°É ¾ðÁ¦ ´Ù ´Ý¾ÆÁÖ³ª.... Read More

Right Wing News had some useful information today, in the form of their experience with a Movabletype plug-in [Movabletype is blogging software if you didn't know...]. I've installed MT-close and opened up comments again to see how it goes. In... Read More

Installing MT-Captcha (aka SCode) from Digital Life the OS X way on May 13, 2005 8:37 PM

This site has recently started to attract spammers, extolling the virtues of viagra, cialis, and large penises in general. Since the Movable Type interface is relatively slow, deleting these spams has become a bit of a pain. There are several... Read More

I might have beat spam thanks to this MT diddley-wop that someone came up with where you can close comments on old entries. Spam has become the bane of my MT existence mainly because I refuse to give up and let the spammers win. I spend 10 minutes a da... Read More

Comments are back from noise to signal on August 4, 2005 9:48 AM

Looks like Lunarpages shut down commenting on my site because of the high server loads the comment script was generating. We have some disagreement about what's causing that, but they have graciously restored the script as long as it doesn't... Read More

37 Comments

Got a problem - when I run it, I get this error from MT: 'Can't modify non-lvalue subroutine call at mt-close.cgi line 88.'. I uploaded it as ASCII and set the permissions correctly, so I'm hoping you'll have some idea. I'm using MySQL as the database, and on most of the entries the comments are closed already anyway.

thanks for this plugin mate, but was just wondering if its able to config it so it can only close certain categories, some I wish to keep open

Is there some limitation on the number of days you can set? I tried to shut off comments to all threads older than 45 days, and it appears to have done nothing at all. I posted a couple of test comments myself just to make sure.

Any chance of making this reversable? Or keeping some sort of record as to which records /used to/ support comments and trackbacks?

I have it barraging me by the second. I deleted the mt-comment.cgi and am trying to get the mt-close.cgi script to work. I placed it in the cgi-bin where all the other MT cgi script reside and set the permissions so it could do everything, and when I tried to access it, I got this error:

Internal Server Error
The server encountered an internal error or misconfiguration and was unable to complete your request.
Please contact the server administrator, webmaster@tiglaw.com and inform them of the time the error occurred, and anything you might have done that may have caused the error.
More information about this error may be available in the server error log.
Apache/1.3.27 Server at tiglaw.com Port 80
I am sure I did something wrong, as it took me a couple of days to install MT initially. HELP!

Is this reversible? Even manually?

This script wont work for me? MT 2.661, MT-Blacklist and Berkeley DB. I select the options on the form. It goes back to the server and then simply comes back to my browser with the same form and no entries have been closed?

Just as "steve" reported on Feb 9, the script doesn't seem to work. I can submit the form and a second later it just seems to refresh the page and that's it. I'm guessing it only works on systems setup to use MySQL DB (steve and I are just using Berkeley DB). I'm running MT 2.63.

Can someone please confirm this?

Just as "steve" reported on Feb 9, the script doesn't seem to work. I can submit the form and a second later it just seems to refresh the page and that's it. I'm guessing it only works on systems setup to use MySQL DB (steve and I are just using Berkeley DB). I'm running MT 2.63.

Can someone please confirm this?

Once I've executed and closed all the comments, do I set the permissions back to the way it was before?

Thanks.

Hello, I'm having the same problem that Steven and Derek Tom are having, posts 41-43. Is this a bug? Can anyone help us?

i, too, am having the refresh problem cited above by steve et al...using mt 2.661

"Me, too!" I'm seeing the same type of problem that has been previously reported. Given that the first occurrences didn't appear to receive any help, I'm not hopeful.

David, can you please offer us any assistance?

Could mt-close.cgi be modified for "no comments" rather than "closed," that is, 0 rather than 1?

*sob* I'm getting hammered with comment spam and want to close my old comments, but this script didn't work. It installed correctly, but when I execute it, nothing happens. All my old comments are still open!

doesnt anyone answer the questions as to why this doesnt work? Someone? Is this mike on?

Meh. Did not work for me either.

Well, I can run it alright, but then it just sits around forever until it finally 404s without closing anything whatsoever.

It's not closing any comments for me, either. It just runs and does nothing. I'm running MT 2.661 and the MT Blacklist.

From the "Beggars Can't Be Choosers" file, what I would really like to be able to do is, rather than closing comments for posts over n days old, instead close comments for posts that have not been commented on in over n days. Any script hack make that possible?

Obviously nobody has any answers here, and obviously MT Close doesn't work here either.

Obviously nobody answers these questions.

This script, as is, does not work for me. But... I debugged it a little and changed it so that it will work for me. (I suspect the problem is due to not using mysql but I'm not sure).

I'd like to extend it a bit (so you can turn off comments per category, turn _on_ comments and pings and filter by "activity")?

If anyone's interested, I've e-mailed David Raynes twice and have received no response.

So what changes did you make, Mark? I'm also not using mysql, and like many others, this script is doing nothing for me. Can you post your changes so that maybe some of us can get this working (seeing as it appears that David doesn't read these comments)?